Inkmuse ~ Pimp your PoV! #amwriting



Click to read chapter 1!



We hoped that Florida based author / editor / reviewer Rebecca Hamilton (AKA Inkmuse) would give us the benefit of her experience - when it comes to sharpening up your writing - by making a guest appearance here.
~
Her recent novel, The Forever Girl has aroused the interest of HarperCollins and we've heard a rumour that it's caught another industry eye ... and ... she also has another secret, avant-garde project bubbling away (oops!) ... and she's a fantastic word-smith.

Thank you so much, Rebecca! Please take the time to visit Rebecca's site.

Rebecca Hamilton
Follow her on Twitter!
Facebook Fan page

Follow the 'Inkmuse' and Transform Your Point of View!

Whether we are reading third person or first, we want to feel close to the Point of View (POV) character. We want to experience the story with them. This well known trick I’m about to show you does something a little more though. It will improve several areas of your writing in one shot! Bang! Exclamation point! Get excited, this one is fun!

Not only will you bring the reader closer to the character’s experience, you will also (in many cases) find you have used fewer words. Looking for words to cut in your manuscript? This might be your answer. Readers love brevity, and to boot, it will increase the pace while at the same time enhancing the experience.

o.O.o.O.o

So let’s take a look at what we’re talking about here.

Example 1: Mary could hear the birds singing outside. (Distant)

Closer: Mary HEARD the birds singing outside. (Weak)

Close: The birds sang outside. (Strong)

Notes: In the first example We’re three words in before we know what Mary is hearing “the birds singing outside”. When we seek to tighten that up a little, we are two words in before we are inside her experience. But it’s still weak. Why? It’s still weak because if we are in Mary’s close POV, then any sounds described we know to be sounds she is hearing. When we master this line, we’ve found we are directly inside the experience. When we are in Mary’s POV, and we read “The birds sang outside” we have stepped into Mary’s shoes and hear the birds with her. It’s no longer ONLY her experience. We know she is experiencing it, because it’s her POV, but now we are included in the experience.

This, I believe, is one of the reasons you will see writing advice say to watch out for words like see, heard, tasted, smelled, felt. Let’s look at more examples.

o.O.o.O.o

Example 2: Alice could see Mark through the window.

Closer: Alice saw Mark through the window.

Close: On the other side of the window, Mark paced in the living room.

Notes: In this example we do lose brevity, but we are more inside of the experience. We not only know Alice saw Mark, but we know what Mark was doing when she saw him. Another option might be: Alice glared at Mark through the window. These are all basic examples–nothing fancy here–but hopefully you can see the benefit of cutting the distance. In the example given in these notes you get an idea of how Alice is feeling about Mark as she looks at him through the window (because of how she looks at him–glaring). We haven’t used the word felt here either though.

Imagine these two lines together: Alice could see Mark through the window. She felt angry at him. Fixed: Alice glared at Mark through the window. Here, we’ve condensed two lines into one, using fewer words, and brought the reader closer to the experience.
o.O.o.O.o
Example 3: Mary could feel the rough bark of the tree as she felt her way through the forest.
Closer: Mary felt the rough tree bark as she felt her way through the forest.
Close: Tree bark scraped her fingertips as she felt her way through the forest.
Notes: The final example is only a word shorter than the previous one, but it’s more of an experience for the reader. It’s five words shorter than original though, and much closer to the POV character’s experience.
o.O.o.O.o
When your distance is preventing you from showing.
This can happen a lot with emotion on several levels.
Example 1: Mary felt sad. (This is sometimes an attempt to cut a “was” ... Mary was sad - but more about this on another day).
What does sadness feel like? How does sadness affect Mary?
Close: Mary’s heart sank.
Notes: This is cliché. You can do better.
Example 2: Mary was feeling tired.
Closer: Mary felt tired.
Close: Mary’s eyelids drooped.
Depending on the context, you can build more from this. Please keep in mind, showing does not always mean more words, but in this example it will.
Mary’s eyelids drooped. As her car swerved, she jerked her head up and blinked. Two more miles to home. She slapped her face a few times, trying to keep alert.
Notes: Why might this wordier example be a better way to show Mary is tired? Because it gives us a reason to be concerned about her. Is she going to crash her car? She’s so tired she can barely stay awake. She almost nodded off at the wheel and only the sudden swerve of the car awoke her. Perhaps some readers might think she is being foolish, wishing she would just pull over. Here is an opportunity. Maybe she will get in a car accident. Maybe she shouldn’t be as tired as she is. Maybe someone drugged her drink at the work party she just left. Depending on the context of the story, you may have more words, but the subtext of what you provide might make up for it. When it comes to what you are showing, it will all depend on your story. You want to spend more page time on the important parts of the story. But I’m getting ahead of myself. Show versus tell is another post for another day.
o.O.o.O.o
Another aspect of Distance.
Another thing to consider in staying close to your character, is how to write in your character’s POV. If your character sees a little girl with round cheeks, would she call them “fat” cheeks? Would she say the girl had an “Angelic face”. Would your character call the cheeks “chubby” or “cherubic”? More than that, would your character even notice the little girl’s cheeks?
Think of it this way… if you were in the mall, what stores would you notice as you walked by? What stores would your best friend notice? What stores would your parents notice? What stores would a five year old notice? What does the room look like to someone who is 6′5? What if they are 4′10? What stands out to you in your house? Probably nothing, unless it’s out of place. What about a burglar? What about a friend visiting for the first time?
To keep a close narrative distance, you want to notice WHAT your character would notice and HOW they would notice it. Perhaps a man thinks the vase on the table is yellow, but a woman might think it’s buttercup. Perhaps the vase on the table is filled with flowers, perhaps it’s filled with azaleas. Perhaps your character wouldn’t even notice the flowers. Maybe they would notice wallpaper stained by cigarette smoke, or dust on the ceiling fans. Perhaps they would notice the gleam of the granite counter tops, or perhaps they would notice the knife set next to the microwave.
And how does your character feel about what they see? Is a coffee cup just a coffee cup, or is a coffee cup that time her ex-husband threw a mug at her and it smashed on the floor? Step in your characters shoes and see the world through their eyes.
o.O.o.O.o
Using distance intentionally.
You don’t always have to be close. If you read a book where you are always close to the POV character, having a scene with distance could have a powerful impact on the reader. Perhaps it’s a dream scene, perhaps they are drugged, or perhaps they just received some really bad news. In these cases, it may be more powerful to say something like: I could feel the glass slipping from my hand. It felt like hours had passed before I heard it shatter. My hearing seemed muffled, as if my ears were stuffed with cotton.
Alone, that may not seem like much, but when you have kept a close distance in all of your writing surrounding these moments, the reader will subconsciously take in a distant feel. You open the door for more emotional impact.
This is inline with my usual way of thinking: Absolutes will do you no good. Some “rules” are meant to be broken. It’s all about knowing the when and why of breaking them.

15 comments:

  1. Great post! I have soooo much to learn with this. I can get it down to the "weak" version, but the strong versions elude me.

    ReplyDelete
  2. @Selestiele: Inkmuse has the knack of getting across to us that which we are struggling to see the simplicity of ... and in simple terms too. In fact, I'm relishing including this simple filter/tool when I revise first drafts.

    ReplyDelete
  3. If it helps, here are the most common "red flag" words that *may* indicate an opportunity for a closer POV *if* a closer POV is needed.

    saw, see, hear, taste, smell, felt, feel, watch, knew, realized

    (I knew I shouldn't have done that >> I shouldn't have done that)
    (I realized it was the last time I'd ever see him. >> It was the last time I'd ever see him.)

    Sometimes it's a matter of cutting words. Other times it's a matter of being more specific or showing more visually or emotionally--either the characters own actions or the actions of who/what they are observing/experiencing.

    That said, those words do *not* always indicate a need for change. Sometimes a change isn't possible, or the possible changes are just awkward and/or overwritten.

    Take on the changes that are an improvement. Leave it alone otherwise. And remember that a moment of distance can sometimes create a desired effect of the character feeling "disconnected" or "overwhelmed" -- an intentional distancing because they can't handle being close to the experience at that time, and that is conveyed to the reader with intentional use of distance.

    Thanks again for having me as a guest blogger. I'll check back to answer questions.

    ReplyDelete
  4. On Distance: Inkmuse, I tried to convey distance in a WiP but a small (but good) proportion of writers I asked saw it more as understatement (J Riley was one).
    The MC is an old guy who returns from a war reunion to find his wife suffering from a stroke; brought on by rogue traders ... he gets her to hospital with a bit of drama on the way. I tried to use distance - is there a better way - did distance come across? (I realize it's hard to evaluate from an excerpt):

    "Doctor Kaur’s face reflected sadness as she approached and led him into a side room. Vic sat down to hear the news, he knew it wasn’t good but maybe–

    “Mr Williams ... I’m so sorry to have to tell you that your wife has just passed away.”
    “Oh ...” He should never have left her on her own. She was on her own.
    “We did everything we could, but I’m afraid time is of the essence when it comes to recovery from a stroke.”
    “Yes, yes I know.”

    She showed Vic into the emergency room. Marg’s eyes were closed, her face waxen and serene. After a while he softly kissed her still warm forehead. His hand brushed a cheek. If only it was all a terrible dream.

    Dr Kaur caught Vic on his way out. “Mr Williams, the bereavement office is next to the outpatients entrance. They can help you with counselling, funeral arrangements and obtain the death certificate for you. They’re open office hours.”

    That’s it. She’s gone. My fault for leaving her. Bloody fool.

    “Are you okay, Mr Williams?”

    Vic walked back to his car. He eased his aching frame into the drivers’ seat and looked at the flowers on the passenger side. His throat tightened. A tear rolled down his cheek.
    Then another.
    More followed in their tracks until he could taste the salt of his grief."

    ReplyDelete
  5. Well, the first thing you’ll want to do is ask yourself why you are using the distance. In one of my works, I use distance intentionally twice. Once when my MC’s house burns down, and another time when she is delivered some pretty heavy news.
    I use lines like “My fingers dialed the numbers.” Which would normally be a no-no., having body parts acting on their own instead of the MC acting, but this was intentional, to show her body on auto pilot, doing things she was not consciously deciding to do. I also use more “I could hear” and “I could feel” and things like that in those scenes, though not for every sentence. It’s a state of mind I’m trying to convey more than anything else there. I usually, in those scenes, give more fragmented summaries. Like having my character in one room and then “suddenly” somewhere else, without any narration of the time in-between. I want to show disconnect. That said, there are surely varying degrees of distance. Also keep in mind, this is just how *I* personally do it… others may achieve distance in ways unique to them.
    I’ve made some notes on your work belong. If anything I say resonates, feel free to take it on board. I advise ignoring anything that doesn’t resonate or at least giving yourself more time to consider before making changes.

    [Doctor Kaur’s face reflected sadness]
    Can you show the doctor’s expression here, something that conveys sadness?
    If you want more distance, you could say something like. Doctor Kaur was frowning when she approached him and led him to a side room, and Vic found himself sitting in that chair he didn’t want to be sitting in, knowing he was going to hear news he didn’t want to hear. But maybe—
    That said, if you think the distance isn’t working, you wouldn’t want to make it more distant.
    [“Mr Williams ... I’m so sorry to have to tell you that your wife has just passed away.”]
    To show more compassion from the doctor, have her sorry that the wife has passed away instead of sorry “to have to tell him”. “Mr Williams, I’m so sorry. Your wife has passed away.”

    [ He should never have left her on her own. She was on her own.]
    I’d cut the second line.

    [She showed Vic into the emergency room.]
    This isn’t distant. If you wanted it to be distant, you could say…. “Vic could barely feel his legs as he rose from his chair and followed the doctor into the emergency room. The room was filled with people who still had a chance of living. People who weren’t his wife.
    (the doctor) led him to Marg’s room. Her eyes were closed…

    If you want more distance here: [After a while he softly kissed her still warm forehead.]
    His lips kissed her still warm forehead, his hand brushed a cheek. A terrible dream, he thought. Please let this be a terrible dream.

    If you want a closer POV:
    He gently pressed his lips to her still warm forehead and brushed his hand over her cheek. Don’t be gone, Marg. Don’t let this be real.

    [outpatients entrance.]
    Outpatient entrance, without an s, is how they usually say it. But if you want outpatients, you need the apostrophe before the s.
    From there to “Vic walked back to his car.” I thought was excellent.
    If you want more distance with Vic walked back to his car, you could try:
    Then Vic was in his car, with his hand trembling too much to get the key into the ignition. (Distant) He threw his keys on passenger seat beside him—the seat Marg should be sitting in. The keys crushed the flower arrangement that now awaited no one. His throat tightened. A tear rolled down his cheek.
    Then another.
    More followed in their tracks until he could taste [WAS] the salt of his grief. (missing word)

    I don’t think that you necessarily wrote with distance, but if you did, it might have a neat affect. You could get into the character’s head a bit more to show emotion, which may help the reader connect. See what you think.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Yes I do want more detachment now that you have shown me the artifices you are using (you make it seem so simple really). I have always struggled with writing this kind of scene but I do feel more confident - and inspired - now you have shown me a working example. When time allows, I will rewrite according to your advice (this was written 4-5 years ago) and post it up. Looking back on this early work, I can see I tried to do to much with dialog (or lack of). The problem with my early work is a disproportion in 'showing' - easy to be pressured by the style police - when clearly 'telling' is actually 'showing' by virtue of the narrative style/tricks.

    Inkmuse; you rock!

    ReplyDelete
  7. *and ... I love that intimate 'don't be gone, Marg' - an added pointer to where I can exploit the situation further. Like the 'gone' word; I see it is more palatable than 'dead' and realize these euphemisms are common for that purpose ...

    ReplyDelete
  8. I'd love to see the "after" for a comparison :)

    With death scenes, keeping things a little understated can create more effect. Otherwise, there is the risk of melodrama. It's better to let the reader feel, and show the character's emotion as quietly and naturally as possible. Scenes like these aren't easy to write.

    And you hit a point. Showing isn't always about writing action (read: movement) after action (movement). Showing can be more oblique than that, something between the lines. Sometimes it's done in thought.

    IE:

    Jenna thought she was so perfect, with her fake eyelashes and fake boobies and fake laugh. Guess you'd have to be fake to be perfect, though. God forbid anyone ever saw the monster hiding under her facade of thick foundation, dark red lipstick, and crest whitening strips.

    I made that up and it's not great, but it's the perfect example of showing that the character does not like Jenna. Much more effective than "I don't like Jenna."

    ReplyDelete
  9. Some very good points. You've put into words what I had scarcely thought about.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Thanks, Marj :) Some people write this way naturally. Others don't give it any thought and don't see a need to. But if anyone is interested in deepening POV, or checking to see if their work is written via deep POV or distant POV, I hope this article will help!

    ReplyDelete
  11. Interesting post!
    I always write too distant, until I noticed that when I write in first POV I write much closer, so I started writing in first POV and then changed it to third person, which made it feel much more closer than what it would have if I had written it in third from the beginning.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Though I haven't polished the revision, I think it has helped the piece and the way I will approach distance in future:

    OLD VERSION:
    Doctor Kaur’s face reflected sadness as she approached and led him into a side room. Vic sat down to hear the news, he knew it wasn’t good but maybe–

    “Mr Williams ... I’m so sorry to have to tell you that your wife has just passed away.”
    “Oh ...” He should never have left her on her own. She was on her own.
    “We did everything we could, but I’m afraid time is of the essence when it comes to recovery from a stroke.”
    “Yes, yes I know.”

    She showed Vic into the emergency room. Marg’s eyes were closed, her face waxen and serene. After a while he softly kissed her still warm forehead. His hand brushed a cheek. If only it was all a terrible dream.

    Dr Kaur caught Vic on his way out. “Mr Williams, the bereavement office is next to the outpatients entrance. They can help you with counselling, funeral arrangements and obtain the death certificate for you. They’re open office hours.”

    That’s it. She’s gone. My fault for leaving her. Bloody fool.

    “Are you okay, Mr Williams?”

    Vic walked back to his car. He eased his aching frame into the drivers’ seat and looked at the flowers on the passenger side. His throat tightened. A tear rolled down his cheek.
    Then another.
    More followed in their tracks until he could taste the salt of his grief.

    AFTER TAKING SOME OF INKMUSE'S ADVICE:

    Doctor Kaur’s smile was no longer there as she quietly led him into a side room. She pulled out a chair. Vic shook his head; he didn’t want to sit down for news he didn’t want to hear. But maybe–

    “Mr Williams, I’m so sorry. I’m afraid your wife has passed away.”
    “Oh ...” He should never have left her on her own.
    “We did everything we could, but I’m afraid time is of the essence when it comes to recovery from a stroke.”
    “Yes, yes I know.”
    The fluorescent lights took on a glare and he felt strangely centre stage as he woodenly passed the averted and knowing eyes on the way to the emergency room. Doctor Kaur ushered him through the door but didn’t follow him in. Marg’s eyes were closed, her face waxen and serene. He gently pressed his lips to her still warm forehead and brushed his hand over her cheek. Don’t be gone, Marg. Don’t let this be real.


    Dr Kaur caught Vic on his way out. “Mr Williams, the bereavement office is next to the outpatient entrance. They can help you with counselling, funeral arrangements and obtain the death certificate for you. They’re open office hours.”

    That’s it. She’s gone. My fault for leaving her. Bloody fool.

    “Are you okay, Mr Williams?”

    Then Vic was back at his car. He eased his aching frame into the drivers’ seat and looked at the flowers on the passenger side. Marg’s flowers. His throat tightened. A tear rolled down his cheek.
    Then another.
    More followed in their tracks until he could taste the salt of his grief.

    Comments appreciated ~ thanks, Inkmuse!

    ReplyDelete
  13. I think the new version make a good use of distance! Going with what you have, I might transition the move slightly from hospital to car.

    Maybe something like...

    He didn't answer her. He didn't stop by the bereavement office. In fact, he hadn't even fully processed what she'd said until he was back at his car.

    He eased his...

    See what you think. But I really like the intentional distance in that scene. For me, there is more emotion there than with a close POV. It really all depends on what you're going for, IMHO.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I like both ideas; I like the sudden transition (but I'm a devil for underwriting!) and the expanded version you suggest. Great food for thought, Rebecca; ambrosia!

    Thank you so much!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thank you, Rebecca! This is great. For someone like myself coming from screenwriting to novel writing, I appreciate your expertise.

    Audrey

    ReplyDelete